1 of 21
Most Expensive Cars to Insure
Think Your Car Insurance Is Expensive?
Think again. These 20 cars and trucks have incredibly high premiums and win the dubious award of being the most expensive to insure. The data was compiled by Insure.com, with averages based on a 40-year-old male driver who commutes 12 miles to work, with policy limits of 100/300/50 and a $500 deductible on collision and comprehensive.
- Research More on Car Buying
- Car Insurance
- Dealer Secrets: Fine Print
#20 Most Expensive Car to Insure
Mercedes-Benz
Mercedes-Benz SL-Class
Average Insurance Premium: $1,577
MSRP:$98,500 - $194,700
The Mercedes-Benz SL-Class models are stately, well-constructed two-seat roadsters, created in small volumes for customers with exclusive tastes. The SL-Class is comprised of four models: the SL550, the SL600, the all-new SL63 AMG and the SL65 AMG.
Average Insurance Premium: $1,577
MSRP:$98,500 - $194,700
The Mercedes-Benz SL-Class models are stately, well-constructed two-seat roadsters, created in small volumes for customers with exclusive tastes. The SL-Class is comprised of four models: the SL550, the SL600, the all-new SL63 AMG and the SL65 AMG.
- Research This Expensive Car to Insure
- Mercedes-Benz SL-Class Overview
- Mercedes-Benz Pictures
- Free Mercedes-Benz SL-Class Price Quote
#19 Most Expensive Car to Insure
BMW
BMW X6
Average Insurance Premium: $1,584
MSRP:$55,900 - $66,650
The BMW X6 Sports Activity Coupe combines coupe-like agility and style with the versatility of a SUV. The distinctive 4-door, 4-passenger X6 features two rear seats in a sculpted single-seat design and BMW's xDrive intelligent all-wheel drive system.
Average Insurance Premium: $1,584
MSRP:$55,900 - $66,650
The BMW X6 Sports Activity Coupe combines coupe-like agility and style with the versatility of a SUV. The distinctive 4-door, 4-passenger X6 features two rear seats in a sculpted single-seat design and BMW's xDrive intelligent all-wheel drive system.
- Research This Expensive Car to Insure
- BMW X6 Overview
- BMW X6 Pictures
- Free BMW X6 Price Quote
#18 Most Expensive Car to Insure
Honda
Honda S2000
Average Insurance Premium: $1,587
MSRP:$34,995 - $36,995
The Honda S2000 is a two-seat roadster that?s the size of a small Mazda Miata and has the speed of a Porsche Boxster. A 2.2-liter four-cylinder engine mated to a six-speed manual transmission is equipped to the S2000, producing 237 horsepower and 162 pounds-feet of torque.
Average Insurance Premium: $1,587
MSRP:$34,995 - $36,995
The Honda S2000 is a two-seat roadster that?s the size of a small Mazda Miata and has the speed of a Porsche Boxster. A 2.2-liter four-cylinder engine mated to a six-speed manual transmission is equipped to the S2000, producing 237 horsepower and 162 pounds-feet of torque.
- Research This Expensive Car to Insure
- Honda S2000 Overview
- Honda S2000 Pictures
- Free Honda S2000 Price Quote
#17 Most Expensive Car to Insure
GM
Cadillac Escalade EXT
Average Insurance Premium: $1,592
MSRP:$61,130 - $61,130
The Escalade EXT is a sport utility/pickup combination that quickly converts from a pickup with an enclosable eight-foot bed to a five-passenger luxury vehicle. The EXT deletes the third-row seat found in the standard Escalade in favor of a lined, lockable and enclosable pickup bed.
Average Insurance Premium: $1,592
MSRP:$61,130 - $61,130
The Escalade EXT is a sport utility/pickup combination that quickly converts from a pickup with an enclosable eight-foot bed to a five-passenger luxury vehicle. The EXT deletes the third-row seat found in the standard Escalade in favor of a lined, lockable and enclosable pickup bed.
- Research This Expensive Car to Insure
- Cadillac Escalade EXT Overview
- Cadillac Escalade EXT Pictures
- Free Cadillac Escalade EXT Price Quote
#16 Most Expensive Car to Insure
Land Rover
Land Rover Range Rover
Average Insurance Premium: $1,603
MSRP:$77,675 - $93,325
The Land Rover Range Rover is the brand's most prestigious offering, a luxury sport utility vehicle with a long history of quality craftsmanship and legendary 'go anywhere' off-road prowess.
Average Insurance Premium: $1,603
MSRP:$77,675 - $93,325
The Land Rover Range Rover is the brand's most prestigious offering, a luxury sport utility vehicle with a long history of quality craftsmanship and legendary 'go anywhere' off-road prowess.
- Research This Expensive Car to Insure
- Land Rover Range Rover Overview
- Land Rover Range Rover Pictures
- Free Land Rover Range Rover Price Quote
#15 Most Expensive Car to Insure
Audi
Audi R8
Average Insurance Premium: $1,637
MSRP:$114,200 - $114,200
The Audi R8 is the company's first mid-engine super car. It is designed with extreme performance in mind and with other high end sports cars in its sights.
Average Insurance Premium: $1,637
MSRP:$114,200 - $114,200
The Audi R8 is the company's first mid-engine super car. It is designed with extreme performance in mind and with other high end sports cars in its sights.
- Research This Expensive Car to Insure
- Audi R8 Overview
- Audi R8 Pictures
- Free Audi R8 Price Quote
#14 Most Expensive Car to Insure
GM
Cadillac XLR
Average Insurance Premium: $1,694
MSRP:$86,215 - $86,215
The 2009 XLR is Cadillac's flagship vehicle. This luxurious high-performance two-seat roadster shares the same platform as the Corvette. The Cadillac XLR features a magnetic-fluid-based real-time damping suspension that continually adapts to different road conditions.
Average Insurance Premium: $1,694
MSRP:$86,215 - $86,215
The 2009 XLR is Cadillac's flagship vehicle. This luxurious high-performance two-seat roadster shares the same platform as the Corvette. The Cadillac XLR features a magnetic-fluid-based real-time damping suspension that continually adapts to different road conditions.
- Research This Expensive Car to Insure
- Cadillac XLR Overview
- Cadillac XLR Pictures
- Free Cadillac XLR Price Quote
#13 Most Expensive Car to Insure
BMW
BMW M3
Average Insurance Premium: $1,714
MSRP:$54,850 - $66,500
Now in its fourth generation, the M3 was first launched in 1986 by M GmbH who took what they learned on the race track to develop a high-performance street car that lives up to its motorsports heritage.
Average Insurance Premium: $1,714
MSRP:$54,850 - $66,500
Now in its fourth generation, the M3 was first launched in 1986 by M GmbH who took what they learned on the race track to develop a high-performance street car that lives up to its motorsports heritage.
- Research This Expensive Car to Insure
- BMW M3 Overview
- BMW M3 Pictures
- Free BMW M3 Price Quote
#12 Most Expensive Car to Insure
Jaguar XK
Jaguar XK
Average Insurance Premium: $1,717
MSRP:$82,150 - $101,150
The Jaguar XK receives a subtle redesign for 2010. It continues to combine Jaguar's new modern design style with traditional luxury car touches like genuine wood and softgrain leather.
Average Insurance Premium: $1,717
MSRP:$82,150 - $101,150
The Jaguar XK receives a subtle redesign for 2010. It continues to combine Jaguar's new modern design style with traditional luxury car touches like genuine wood and softgrain leather.
- Research This Expensive Car to Insure
- Jaguar XK Overview
- Jaguar XK Pictures
- Free Jaguar XK Price Quote
#11 Most Expensive Car to Insure
GM
Chevy Cobalt SS
Average Insurance Premium: $1,762
MSRP: $23,525
The Chevrolet Cobalt is available as either a two-door coupe or a four-door sedan, each available in four trims: Base, LS, LT and SS Turbocharged. The SS Turbocharged comes with a 2.0-liter turbocharged four-cylinder engine mated to a five-speed manual transmission.
Average Insurance Premium: $1,762
MSRP: $23,525
The Chevrolet Cobalt is available as either a two-door coupe or a four-door sedan, each available in four trims: Base, LS, LT and SS Turbocharged. The SS Turbocharged comes with a 2.0-liter turbocharged four-cylinder engine mated to a five-speed manual transmission.
- Research This Expensive Car to Insure
- Chevy Cobalt SS Overview
- Chevy Cobalt SS Pictures
- Free Chevy Cobalt SS Price Quote
#10 Most Expensive Car to Insure
Porsche
Porsche 911
Average Insurance Premium: $1,819
MSRP:$75,600 - $139,300
The Porsche 911 remains the iconic symbol of a sports car. The Porsche 911 comes as either a coupe or a cabriolet in either a rear-wheel drive (C2) or an all-wheel drive (C4) configuration and each 911 comes as either a Carrera or the performance variant Carrera S.
Average Insurance Premium: $1,819
MSRP:$75,600 - $139,300
The Porsche 911 remains the iconic symbol of a sports car. The Porsche 911 comes as either a coupe or a cabriolet in either a rear-wheel drive (C2) or an all-wheel drive (C4) configuration and each 911 comes as either a Carrera or the performance variant Carrera S.
- Research This Expensive Car to Insure
- Porsche 911 Overview
- Porsche 911 Pictures
- Free Porsche 911 Price Quote
#9 Most Expensive Car to Insure
Lexus
Lexus IS-F
Average Insurance Premium: $1,881
MSRP:$56,760 - $56,760
The Lexus IS-F is a true performance sedan that can run with the likes of the BMW M3. Lexus take the IS and stuffs a huge 5.0-liter V8 under the hood that produces a ridiculous 416-hp.
Average Insurance Premium: $1,881
MSRP:$56,760 - $56,760
The Lexus IS-F is a true performance sedan that can run with the likes of the BMW M3. Lexus take the IS and stuffs a huge 5.0-liter V8 under the hood that produces a ridiculous 416-hp.
- Research This Expensive Car to Insure
- Lexus IS-F Overview
- Lexus IS-F Pictures
- Free Lexus IS-F Price Quote
#8 Most Expensive Car to Insure
GM
Hummer H2
Average Insurance Premium: $1,912
MSRP: $63,090 - $63,090
The H2 SUV provides the power, size, ruggedness and iconic design expected from a HUMMER. Power comes from a flexible-fuel 393-hp, 6.2-liter Vortec V8 and is controlled by a six-speed automatic transmission with steering wheel mounted shift buttons.
Average Insurance Premium: $1,912
MSRP: $63,090 - $63,090
The H2 SUV provides the power, size, ruggedness and iconic design expected from a HUMMER. Power comes from a flexible-fuel 393-hp, 6.2-liter Vortec V8 and is controlled by a six-speed automatic transmission with steering wheel mounted shift buttons.
- Research This Expensive Car to Insure
- Hummer H2 Overview
- Hummer H2 Pictures
- Free Hummer H2 Price Quote
#7 Most Expensive Car to Insure
BMW
BMW M5
Average Insurance Premium: $2,020
MSRP: $85,500 - $85,500
The limited-production M5 can out-accelerate, out-brake and out-corner some of the most expensive sports cars, with comfortable seating for five. The M5 sits atop the 5-series lineup. It's powered by a hand-built 500-hp 5.0-liter V10, with suspension and brakes enhanced to match all the power.
Average Insurance Premium: $2,020
MSRP: $85,500 - $85,500
The limited-production M5 can out-accelerate, out-brake and out-corner some of the most expensive sports cars, with comfortable seating for five. The M5 sits atop the 5-series lineup. It's powered by a hand-built 500-hp 5.0-liter V10, with suspension and brakes enhanced to match all the power.
- Research This Expensive Car to Insure
- BMW M5 Overview
- BMW M5 Pictures
- Free BMW M5 Price Quote
#6 Most Expensive Car to Insure
Audi
Audi S8
Average Insurance Premium: $2,071
MSRP:$96,200 - $96,200
The S8 is the performance-enhanced flagship of Audi's lineup. It is based off the A8 luxury sedan and features all the cutting edge innovation that Audi has to offer. The S8 is powered by a 5.2-liter 450-hp V10, similar to the engine found in the Lamborghini Gallardo.
Average Insurance Premium: $2,071
MSRP:$96,200 - $96,200
The S8 is the performance-enhanced flagship of Audi's lineup. It is based off the A8 luxury sedan and features all the cutting edge innovation that Audi has to offer. The S8 is powered by a 5.2-liter 450-hp V10, similar to the engine found in the Lamborghini Gallardo.
- Research This Expensive Car to Insure
- Audi S8 Overview
- Audi S8 Pictures
- Free Audi S8 Price Quote
#5 Most Expensive Car to Insure
Mercedes-Benz
Mercedes-Benz G-Class
Average Insurance Premium: $2,088
MSRP:$100,250 - $119,450
The Mercedes-Benz G-Class is a luxury off-road vehicle with a military heritage that was designed for the rugged outdoors. The G-Class is available with two different engines: a 5.5-liter V8 in the G500, and a 500-hp 5.5-liter supercharged V8 in the AMG-tuned G55.
Average Insurance Premium: $2,088
MSRP:$100,250 - $119,450
The Mercedes-Benz G-Class is a luxury off-road vehicle with a military heritage that was designed for the rugged outdoors. The G-Class is available with two different engines: a 5.5-liter V8 in the G500, and a 500-hp 5.5-liter supercharged V8 in the AMG-tuned G55.
- Research This Expensive Car to Insure
- Mercedes-Benz G-Class Overview
- Mercedes-Benz G-Class Pictures
- Free Mercedes-Benz G-Class Price Quote
#4 Most Expensive Car to Insure
Ford
Ford Shelby GT500
Average Insurance Premium: $2,186
MSRP: $46,325 - $51,325
Redesigned for 2010, the Shelby GT500 builds on its 1960's muscle car heritage. This newest rendition features classic cues and aggressive modern styling touches, mixed with a massive dose of horsepower.
Average Insurance Premium: $2,186
MSRP: $46,325 - $51,325
Redesigned for 2010, the Shelby GT500 builds on its 1960's muscle car heritage. This newest rendition features classic cues and aggressive modern styling touches, mixed with a massive dose of horsepower.
- Research This Expensive Car to Insure
- Ford Shelby GT500 Overview
- Ford Shelby GT500 Pictures
- Free Ford Shelby GT500 Price Quote
#3 Most Expensive Car to Insure
BMW
BMW M6
Average Insurance Premium: $2,236
MSRP: $102,100 - $107,900
The BMW M6 is a more powerful version of the elegant 650. Available as either a coupe or a convertible, it is designed to appeal to the sport luxury enthusiast, providing heightened performance and subtly aggressive styling.
Average Insurance Premium: $2,236
MSRP: $102,100 - $107,900
The BMW M6 is a more powerful version of the elegant 650. Available as either a coupe or a convertible, it is designed to appeal to the sport luxury enthusiast, providing heightened performance and subtly aggressive styling.
- Research This Expensive Car to Insure
- BMW M6 Overview
- BMW M6 Pictures
- Free BMW M6 Price Quote
#2 Most Expensive Car to Insure
Dodge
Dodge Viper
Average Insurance Premium: $2,446
MSRP: $88,590 - $89,340
The Dodge Viper is a very powerful, two-door, performance sports car. Since its original debut in 1992, the Viper has garnered a reputation as a serious high-end performance car with a very sleek and distinctive appearance.
Average Insurance Premium: $2,446
MSRP: $88,590 - $89,340
The Dodge Viper is a very powerful, two-door, performance sports car. Since its original debut in 1992, the Viper has garnered a reputation as a serious high-end performance car with a very sleek and distinctive appearance.
- Research This Expensive Car to Insure
- Dodge Viper Overview
- Dodge Viper Pictures
- Free Dodge Viper Price Quote
#1 Most Expensive Car to Insure
Nissan
Nissan GT-R
Average Insurance Premium: $2,533
MSRP:$80,790 - $83,040
The Nissan GT-R is the fifth generation of this venerable Japanese supercar, but this is the first generation available to North American enthusiasts. Well known to video gamers in this part of the world as forbidden fruit, the GT-R brings new levels of performance and technology to Nissan's line-up.
Average Insurance Premium: $2,533
MSRP:$80,790 - $83,040
The Nissan GT-R is the fifth generation of this venerable Japanese supercar, but this is the first generation available to North American enthusiasts. Well known to video gamers in this part of the world as forbidden fruit, the GT-R brings new levels of performance and technology to Nissan's line-up.
- Research This Expensive Car to Insure
- Nissan GT-R Overview
- Nissan GT-R Pictures
- Free Nissan GT-R Price Quote
Automotive Guides
See all that we have to offer on these topics:
