- You are here:
- Pictures >
- The Best And Worst Vehicles For Passenger Safety
The Best And Worst Vehicles For Passenger Safety
Insure.com recently released results of a study that evaluated passenger safety in more than 750 vehicles. The study analyzed insurance rates for Personal Injury Protection (PIP) and Medical Payments (MedPay) – coverage that pays for injuries to your passengers in a crash. Simply put: The lower the rates, the safer the car for passengers.
Though the study doesn't get into the nitty-gritty details about what makes some of the cars perform badly, all in all, the results showed that bigger is better when it comes to this type of safety.
"It's not just the size, but also that there's more room between the occupants and what they will interact with," said Pete Leiss, head of crash practice at Lancaster, Pa.-based Robson Forensic.
Though small cars often perform well in crash tests, Insure.com said, sheer size of your car will ultimately go further in protecting your passengers. Click on through to see which vehicles are the best for passenger safety, and which are the worst.
Sticker Price: $46,335 - $65,680
Invoice Price: $43,092 - $61,082
Fuel Economy: 16 mpg City, 23 mpg Highway
Completely redesigned for the 2015 model year, the GMC Yukon can seat a lot of people both comfortably and safely. Safety features standard on all Yukons include four-wheel anti-lock brakes, StabiliTrak stability control system with rollover mitigation, seven airbags, including a new center mounted front airbag, tire pressure monitoring system, rear vision camera and OnStar with Automatic Crash Response.
The Yukon isn't cheap, but you get a lot for your money, including all kinds of comfort and tech features.
Research the GMC Yukon
GMC Yukon Overview
GMC Yukon Photos & Video
GMC Yukon Local Dealer Price Quote
Sticker Price: $30,035 - $47,520
Invoice Price: $27,707 - $43,837
Fuel Economy: NA
The big, burly F-250 is one of Ford's heavy-duty truck offerings. It boasts loads of torque and a high towing capacity, as well as numerous safety features that help to keep passengers safe.
In addition to its large size, the F-250 works to ensure its occupants safety with traction control and electronic stability control, a hill launch assist feature and side curtain airbags. Available safety features include a reverse camera system and stolen vehicle tracking system.
Research the Ford F-250
Ford F-250 Overview
Ford F-250 Photos & Video
Ford F-250 Local Dealer Price Quote
Sticker Price: $49,600 - $146,000No. 3 Best - Porsche Cayenne
Invoice Price: NA
Fuel Economy: 15 mpg City, 22 mpg Highway
Legendary Porsche driving prowess comes in SUV form with the Cayenne. In addition to great driving dynamics and luxury, the Cayenne also benefits from having a wide range of safety features, including Porsche Stability Management (PSM), Porsche Active Suspension Management (PASM) and Porsche Dynamic Chassis Control (PDCC).
Research the Porsche Cayenne
Porsche Cayenne Overview
Porsche Cayenne Photos & Video
Porsche Cayenne Local Dealer Price Quote
Sticker Price: $31,565 - $53,740No. 2 Best - GMC Sierra 2500
Invoice Price: $29,671 - $49,978
Fuel Economy: NA
The big, burly Sierra 2500 is available in a wide array of bed sizes, wheelbases, drive types and cab sizes, as well as a variety of trim levels. Stability control, hill start assist and a trailer sway control system are standard on the Sierra 2500 and its large size and sturdy construction make it very safe for passengers.
The Sierra is more expensive than the Chevrolet Silverado, which is a very similar truck, but it comes with a nicer interior and more features.
Research the GMC Sierra 2500
GMC Sierra 2500 Overview
GMC Sierra 2500 Photos & Video
GMC Sierra 2500 Local Dealer Price Quote
Sticker Price: $31,940 - $50,730
Invoice Price: $29,464 - $46,798
Fuel Economy: NA
The F-350, which is another Heavy Duty offering from Ford, topped the list as the safest cars for passengers, according to Insure.com. Its massive size is obviously an asset when it comes to safety, but the truck also comes numerous standard safety features (most of which can also be found on the F-250) such as traction control, electronic stability control, a hill launch assist feature and side curtain airbags.
Research the Ford F-350
Ford F-350 Overview
Ford F-350 Photos & Video
Ford F-350 Local Dealer Price Quote
Sticker Price: $11,990 - $16,890
Invoice Price: $11,703 - $16,465
Fuel Economy: 27 mpg City, 36 mpg Highway
In general, we've been pretty pleased with what we've seen from Nissan's offering in the small sedan segment. The Versa was recently redesigned with new styling and a new interior. Passenger safety, however, is not this car's forte, according to Insure.com.
Research the Nissan Versa
Nissan Versa Overview
Nissan Versa Photos & Video
Nissan Versa Local Dealer Price Quote
Sticker Price: $17,195 - $28,395
Invoice Price: $16,469 - $27,196
Fuel Economy: 25 mpg City, 34 mpg Highway
The Mitsubishi Lancer has hung around for quite some time now, in spite of slow sales and low name recognition. The car can be had in a couple of exciting trims and engine configurations, such as the Ralliart and Evolution, but it's still at the bottom of the totem pole in this segment. Passenger safety is just one issue with this car.
Research the Mitsubishi Lancer
Mitsubishi Lancer Overview
Mitsubishi Lancer Photos & Video
Mitsubishi Lancer Local Dealer Price Quote
Sticker Price: $16,800 - $21,300
Invoice Price: $15,876 - $19,722
Fuel Economy: 28 mpg City, 37 mpg Highway
Toyota's recent redesign of the Corolla helped its looks and its interior, but didn't do much for passenger safety. This small sedan is the third-worst on Insure.com's list, which is the exact same position the previous-generation Corolla was in last year.
Research the Toyota Corolla
Toyota Corolla Overview
Toyota Corolla Photos & Video
Toyota Corolla Local Dealer Price Quote
MSRP: $16,195 - $22,195No. 2 Worst - Fiat 500
Invoice: $15,801 - $21,381
Fuel Economy: 31 mpg City, 40 mpg Highway
The second-worst car for passenger safety, according to the study, is the Fiat 500. The little Italian hatchback boasts bold styling and great fuel economy, but passenger safety is a concern across all trim levels.
Occupants are protected by seven airbags, active front head restraints, electronic stability and traction control and a tire pressure monitoring system, but the reality is that this teeny car is going to lose almost every time it's in a collision.
Research the Fiat 500
Fiat 500 Overview
Fiat 500 Photos & Video
Fiat 500 Local Dealer Price Quote
Sticker Price: $14,430 - $16,540
Invoice Price: $13,853 - $15,877
Fuel Economy: 30 mpg City, 37 mpg Highway
Toyota's small hatchback is this year's worst car for passenger safety, according to the study. The Yaris comes with safety features like anti-lock brakes with electronic brake-force distribution and brake assist, electronic stability and traction control, whiplash-lessening front seats, front seatbelt pretensioners and nine airbags. But the reality is this is a small, cramped car, much like the Fiat 500, making it a fundamentally more dangerous place to be a passenger.
Research the Toyota Yaris
Toyota Yaris Overview
Toyota Yaris Photos & Video
Toyota Yaris Local Dealer Price Quote
Most Popular Auto News
- Los Angeles: 2015 Toyota Prius V gets updated looks and content
- Los Angeles: Galpin Auto Sports and Fisker turn the Mustang into a Rocket in LA [w/video]
- Los Angeles: 2016 Acura ILX, for better or worse [UPDATE]
- ETC: Car and Driver 10Best list cracked by Tesla Model S, BMW 3 Series left off
- Video: Jay Leno gifts army vet Challenger Hellcat on Today Show
- Official: Chevy reveals diesel-powered Colorado ZR2 Concept [w/video]
From Our Partners
Research A New Car
- Alfa Romeo
- Aston Martin
- Land Rover